Choosing A New Roof

When it comes to choosing a new roof there's a variety of things to consider like what shape the roof will be, what material to use and what colour to choose 

Choosing a new roof, Handyman magazine,
Read our guide to choosing the best roof for your house

The roof is one of the most important and generally most neglected parts of a house. 

Many homeowners only take the time for repairs when a real problem like falling tiles or a leaking ceiling occurs, or if they’re planning a reno. 

To avoid being surprised by a serious and ultimately costly problem, inspect your roof a few times a year and do maintenance work as required.  

FROM THE INSIDE look for places where the ceiling is sagging and search for signs of water damage or leaking. Also check for sunlight shining through in the attic or the space between the roof and ceiling.

FROM THE OUTSIDE check for missing, damaged or fretted tiles, algae growth signified by dark or greenish stains on tiles, signs of moisture rot or mould on the timber fascia plus general wear and tear.

Doing the research 

A new roof is a big investment, so be certain to choose one you want to live with for the next 50 years.

If the roof needs to be replaced, do the homework to choose the best style and material for the home, comparing prices and installation costs. 

Collect images of the style you like from websites, blogs, display village brochures and magazines to use as a reference when making decisions.

The material affects your entire home. It should look good, withstand the local climate, resist wear and tear, and insulate against sound and heat. 

TIP Check with local council to see if you’re restricted from using certain materials or colours.   

Consider the shape 

The supporting structure of a roof can be a variety of shapes. The degree, pitch or slope is an important consideration. A flatter roof pitch maximises internal height while a steeper pitch allows for faster runoff in wet areas. 

HIPPED roofs have all the sides sloping down toward the walls. 

GABLED is triangular in shape between sloping sections that meet at a peak.

SKILLION is single-pitched with a flat sloping surface like the roof of a shed. 

CONVEX has a simple curved shape that looks like an upside down U.

CRANKED forms a continuous roofline with a curve on top instead of a ridge. 


Sarking is a layer of flexible insulation installed under the roof battens when the home is being built.
Aluminium foil is laminated onto paper or plastic backing with a flame retardant adhesive and fibreglass mesh.
Sarking helps keeps a home insulated from summer heat while retaining warmth in winter. It’s water resistant and weatherproof, stops condensation and is fire retardant as well as being thermally reflective.
TIP Ensure the sarking you buy complies with the Building Code of Australia, specifically with AS/NZS 4200.1. 

roof with sarking, handyman magazine, choosing a new roof,
Sarking is a layer of flexible insulation installed under the roof battens when the home is being built

Concrete tiles 

Cement-based tiles have been around for more than 150 years and have a lifespan of 30 to 50 years. 

They’re strong and suited to all areas and climates, including harsh coastal locations, and while the colour of the tiles is prone to fading they can be resprayed. 

‘Concrete tiles offer a wide selection of profiles and colours with options to suit a range of budgets,’ says Glen Simpkin from Boral. 

TIP The weight of a concrete-tiled roof increases after rain.

house with concrete slate roof, choosing a new roof, handyman magazine
Cement-based tiles have been around for more than 150 years and have a lifespan of 30 to 50 years


Terracotta tiles are lightweight and low-maintenance, and can last from 20 to 75 years. They also feature a vitreous coating that helps them withstand UV and pollutants. 

‘The colour in terracotta will never fade,’ says Linda Tadrosse from CSR Roofing. 

They need to be handled carefully during installation to avoid chipping corners and cracking tiles. Adding reflective foil in the roof, called sarking, improves energy efficiency.

TIP New colour doesn’t stick to the glazed tiles, so they can’t be resprayed.

house with orange terracotta roof, choosing a new roof, handyman magazine,
Terracotta tiles are lightweight and low-maintenance, and can last from 20 to 75 years


Slate tiles are the most durable roofing material with some slate roofs in Europe lasting up to 400 years. 

‘Slate increases the value of a property, it’s a collectable investment. Slate tiles removed from a 150-year-old roof have a good resale value,’ says Sandy Yeates from Bellstone Stone and Slate Specialists. 

When lifespan is taken into account they’re not so expensive but maintenance also costs as fixing slate isn’t a job for the average DIYer.

TIP Matching damaged slates can be hard as no two slates are identical.

house with slate tile roof, choosing a new roof, handyman magazine,
Slate tiles are the most durable roofing material with some slate roofs in Europe lasting up to 400 years

DIY-friendly slate solution 

Fixing slate isn’t usually a job for the average handyperson but new products like Tapco Inspire from Bellstone are changing the rules. 

The tiles feature guidance for nail placement and overlap. It looks like traditional slate but it’s cheaper, weighs less and is quicker to install. 

‘Once Australian builders adjust to installing these slates we believe it could shave $60 to $80 off costs per metre,’ says Sandy Yeates.

Metal roofing 

The corrugated iron sheeting that used to cover the outhouse is no more. 

Modern metal roofing is strong, light and has a low thermal massso it cools quickly on a hot night, improving comfort inside, and lasts a minimum of 25 years. 

‘Steel is lightweight yet extremely strong and durable. And its superior oven-baked finish resists chipping, peeling and cracking. 

‘Plus, it comes in a wide range of colours,’ says Lisa Dent of BlueScope Steel.

When installing metal roofing insulation is essential and contact with lead, copper and CCA-treated timber must be avoided.

Care must be taken when cutting, all metal filings should be removed to prevent rust pitting and cut ends must be refinished. 

TIP Compare metal profiles online at Steel Select

INSULATING A METAL ROOF is crucial to reduce heat load and penetration of noise into metal-roofed homes. This layer is sandwiched between the roof battens and roof sheets. 

It’s made from a blanket of bio-soluble glass wool fibres backed with a double layer of aluminium.

The thermal resistance of insulation, or how well it stops heat transfer, is expressed as an R value, with higher R values representing better insulating properties.

House with colorbond roof, choosing a new roof, handyman magazine,
Modern metal roofing is strong, light and has a low thermal mass

Finding a roofer 

Hiring a professional early on means they can contribute information during the decision-making process. 

Search online for a roofing company or try the Yellow Pages, or talk to manufacturers and suppliers such as BlueScope Steel, CSR Roofing and Boral for advice. 

The best choice usually comes via recommendations with finished results you can inspect. 

Be sure to look at previous work or speak to a former client before making a commitment.

To cost the job get written quotes with full details of the materials to be used and work to be done including the removal of waste. 

Some tradies give you a rough cost estimate over the phone using Google Earth to measure and price your roof.

TIP Remember that the cheapest price isn’t always the best option. 

Learn the lingo

Here are the terms you need to know.

RIDGE is the apex or peak of a roof where the inclined sides meet and is usually covered with a ridge capping.

ROOFING BATTENS are timber or metal members to which roofing material is secured.

BARGE CAPPING is a tile or metal capping that overlaps and waterproofs the exposed edge of a gable roof.

Matching the material to the home 

Choosing a tiling material depends mostly on design preferences. ‘Profiles are synonymous with different styles of home,’ says Michael Monro from Bristile Roofing, so be mindful of making a selection that suits your architecture.

house with high rolled terracotta tile roof, Handyman magazine, choosing a new roof,
High rolled terracotta tiles work best for European-style homes. Image: Getty Images

English manor looking house with shingle look roof tiles, Choosing a new roof, handyman magazine,
Shingle look tiles are appropriate for English manor-type places. Image: Getty Images  

SHINGLE LOOK tiles are appropriate for English manor-type places.
Classic corrugated profiles suit rural or period architecture. Image: Getty Images 


house with slanted steel roof, Handyman magazine, choosing a new roof,
 Slanted steel sheeting is great for modern coastal and suburban houses. Image: Thinkstock

house with streamlines roof and flat tiles, choosing a new roof, handyman magazine,
 Flat tiles suit contemporary homes and give roofs a streamlined look. Image: Thinkstock 

Vote It Up: 

See also

How To Flip A Home Fast

When you’re renovating to sell, aim for neutral and simple interiors

There’s no denying we’re a nation of renovating enthusiasts. And while large-scale renovations traditionally increase as...
Quickly and easily create your dream bathroom
The Sanicompact can be installed without the headache of expensive plumbing work and is the first all-in-one macerating toilet...
Cool your home with an efficient air conditioner
The hot days and warm nights of summer mean that having an efficient way to cool your home is essential.    Air conditioners have...
Protect your home from burglars - Image: iStock
The family home is the biggest investment most of us will ever make, but it’s an unfortunate fact that it can become a target for...
Inspiring Terrace House Renovation

For a sense of cohesiveness and longevity of design, it was important to ensure the new addition sat comfortably alongside the old part of the building

Overlooking this once-dilapidated house in Sydney’s Paddington would have been easy to do.  A former working class inner-city...
Finish External Corners On Plasterboards
Once you have cut and hung plasterboard, you may need to finish external corners. Secure corner beads on all external angles,...